unable to converge creep simulation in workbench

  • Last Post 2 weeks ago
  • Topic Is Solved
gopikrishna posted this 19 March 2020

i need to simulate a round bar for creep in which one end is fixed and other is applied by a tensile load. the problem is my simulation is not converging. i have tried changing substeps, applied fine mesh, rechecked creep constants and units still problem exists. please help me to sort out this problem. 

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
gopikrishna posted this 19 March 2020

please help guys


Attached Files

peteroznewman posted this 19 March 2020

ANSYS staff are not permitted to open attachments. Please insert the images into your post. You can leave them attached also. as that is easier for me to open.

gopikrishna posted this 19 March 2020

gopikrishna posted this 20 March 2020

sir i have inserted the images.

peteroznewman posted this 20 March 2020

Does it fail to converge at the beginning or does it start and fail to converge at the end?

What happens if you set the Initial Substeps to 1000?

gopikrishna posted this 20 March 2020

gopikrishna posted this 20 March 2020

sir , is negative creep constant can be a problem for convergence??

peteroznewman posted this 20 March 2020

I went to the ANSYS Help system, and found the equation for Norton so that I understood the creep model in another discussion.

ANSYS Help > Home > Mechancial APDL > Material Reference > Nonlinear Material Properties > Rate Dependent Plasticity > Creep

The Combined Time Hardening entry says only C1 > 0 and C5 > 0.  

Where did you obtain the creep constants?  What units of stress are required to use those constants?

It seems your solution begins, so you have some results.

Please reply with a snapshot of the graph of maximum displacement vs. time.


gopikrishna posted this 21 March 2020

Sir, i took the values for strain and time from strain vs time plot and transferred those values to APDL. Then using curve fitting in APDL i solved and got the values. My stress value is 18 Mpa and temperature is 900 degree celsius  for a time of 14000 hours




gopikrishna posted this 21 March 2020

gopikrishna posted this 21 March 2020

peteroznewman posted this 21 March 2020

Try setting Minimum Substeps to 1000 since the solution converges a few initial steps.

gopikrishna posted this 23 March 2020

sir, still not converging. Any other solution??.

peteroznewman posted this 23 March 2020

What is the error description on the Solution Output?

lroblek posted this 28 March 2020

How did you get the Combined time hardening coefficients? Via APDL Material models? You have fixed C4=0, so I assume you don't have temperature dependant model.

Try to fix C2=1, C4=0, C6=1 and C7=0 (fixed stress and no temperature dependancy) in the Curve fitting tool and try to run the simualtion again. The creep behaviur curve should be nearly the same (you can compare to the current one that you have). Put fixed values in the Coeff Value, Fix them and click Solve to get new values for the creep simulation.

gopikrishna posted this 30 March 2020

sir , i changed the constants still its showing error

gopikrishna posted this 30 March 2020

sir same error its showing

gopikrishna posted this 30 March 2020

gopikrishna posted this 30 March 2020

force convergence plot

lroblek posted this 31 March 2020

Can you try a constant Creep strain model, such as Norton and put Auto Time Stepping to Program controlled.

Auto Time Stepping on Program controlled

gopikrishna posted this 03 April 2020

sir actually the data is got is only strain vs time data...can you please tell me how to derive creep constants for norton equation

if i try to get the data from APDL i need creep strain rate vs time data that i dont have...can you pls share me the way i can derive these constants for norton.

gopikrishna posted this 06 April 2020

Sir, how i can send you my model to check the actual mistake??

peteroznewman posted this 06 April 2020

When a nonlinear static structural model fails to converge, that can be the expected outcome of the simulation. For example, if the material is Bilinear Isotopic Hardening, with 0 Tangent Modulus, it is perfectly plastic above the yield strength. If a force is the applied load, once the force is high enough to turn the entire section plastic, there is no static equilibrium above the force increment that just converged, every force above that will fail to converge. There is no mistake in the model, that is the natural end of the simulation for a problem where the ultimate load was unknown.

Your model converges for many time steps, then stops converging. Look at the results. Plot the force vs time curve. What does it look like?

  • Liked by
  • gopikrishna
gopikrishna posted this 07 April 2020

Sir, what is the significance of creep limit ratio. what if i put creep limit ratio as zero, because if im assigning creep limit ratio as zero solution is converging!

sir also if we get the creep constants for a material, then with that creep constants can we simulate the model for any stress, temperature, and time values?? i mean the same creep constants can be applied for a specific material for any of its creep simulation??

peteroznewman posted this 07 April 2020

Plot the force vs time curve. I want to see that before I say anything more.

gopikrishna posted this 08 April 2020

thank you Sir, problem is solved. Actually i had some problem with my constants, i was able to find the constants from another experimental data..

gopikrishna posted this 08 April 2020

Sir if i want to do a coupled simulation of thermal cycling with creep, how can i do it. Since creep constants depends on temperature, so during thermal cycling temperature is continuosly changing..can you explain please!

peteroznewman posted this 08 April 2020

Insert a Thermal Condition load and set the temperature for each time step. I have used 1 second time steps but you can use 100 or 1000 seconds as needed.

gopikrishna posted this 09 April 2020

thank you sir, but what about creep constants?? it depends on temperature, therefore it can vary with temperature. So if im doing thermal cycling, temperature is continously varying. In my case temperature is varying between 900 to 400. So should i choose creep constants for 900 or 400 or in between some value and carry out simulation??

gopikrishna posted this 25 April 2020

Sir, whether we will apply damage evolution law for creep simulation??. because in the real case necking is happening at the heat affected area at the center of the bar. In simulation the way it is failing by creep is complately different.

krishna1983 posted this 2 weeks ago

 @Gopikrishna, I am fresher to Ansys Creep analysis. I need some help from you.

I have a reactor, material is 1.25cr-0.5mo. The design temperature is in creep range. So i need to perform creep analysis to obtain creep strain. I have rupture data from ASTM DS-50. 

My material model is Norton (for secondary creep). Then how i derive creep constants from APDL. Kindly explain.

Besides, could you please share your model, so that it will be helpful for my project.

Your help is appreciated.